Teacher providing feedback to bilingual students in a classroom setting.

Syntax errors can lead to misunderstandings, but their impact varies depending on the context and severity of the error. In my experience teaching Science to 5th-grade Spanish bilingual students, syntax errors do not always cause misunderstandings as frequently as other types of mistakes, such as vocabulary errors or mispronunciations. For instance, if a student says, “Photosynthesis is sunlight, water, and carbon dioxide,” even if the syntax is slightly off, the key terms provide enough context to understand the concept. Additionally, natural language is often redundant, allowing listeners to infer meaning even when the syntax is not perfect. For example, “Plants photosynthesis do” can still be understood as “Plants do photosynthesis” because of the familiar subject-verb-object relationship.

In a classroom setting, especially in subjects like Science, immediate feedback and clarification from the teacher can mitigate misunderstandings caused by syntax errors. According to best practices in bilingual education, providing feedback should be timely, specific, descriptive, personal, positive, and corrective. This means providing real-time feedback that is relevant to the learning goals and proficiency levels of the student. For instance, explaining the differences between the students’ first language (L1) and the second language (L2) regarding word order, sentence structures, and grammatical features can help clarify errors. Encouraging code-switching can help students connect both languages, develop metalinguistic awareness, and enhance their syntax understanding. Highlighting similarities and differences in syntax between L1 and L2 also deepens students’ understanding and facilitates knowledge transfer. These strategies collectively ensure that students grasp the correct syntactical structures and can apply them effectively.

However, syntax errors can become more problematic in written communication where immediate clarification is not possibleor when the errors are so severe that they obscure the intended meaning entirely. In such cases, descriptive and corrective feedback becomes crucial. Explaining what the student needs to do to correct an error and improve in the future helps in addressing specific issues related to syntax.

Importance of Syntax in Upper Elementary Grades

Syntax becomes a significant concern as early as the upper elementary grades, around 3rd to 5th grade. This period marks a transition for students from learning to read to reading to learn, as they engage with more complex texts and are expected to produce more sophisticated written and oral language. At this stage, students encounter more complex sentence structures in their textbooks and are expected to comprehend and use academic language accurately. Additionally, students are expected to produce longer and more coherent pieces of writing, where correct syntax is essential for clear and effective communication.

Assignments such as lab reports, research papers, and essays require students to organize their thoughts logically and use syntax accurately to support their arguments and explanations. Additionally, standardized testing becomes more prevalent in the upper elementary grades, assessing students’ reading and writing abilities, including their grasp of syntax. Mastery of syntax is critical for performing well on these exams, which can influence students’ academic trajectories. For bilingual students, mastering the syntax of both languages is vital. Differences in syntactic structures between languages (e.g., subject-verb-object in English vs. subject-verb-object/subject-object-verb in Spanish) need to be addressed to ensure students can switch between languages fluidly and accurately.

Strategies for Effective Feedback on Syntax Errors

Effective feedback on syntax errors should adhere to the following principles to maximize student understanding and improvement:

  1. Timely Feedback: Provide feedback as soon as possible after the error is made to reinforce learning in real-time.
  2. Specific Feedback: Make feedback relevant to the learning goals and proficiency levels, focusing on the exact nature of the syntax error.
  3. Descriptive Feedback: Explain what the student needs to do to correct the error and improve in the future, using clear examples.
  4. Personal Feedback: Tailor feedback to the individual student, considering their specific needs and learning context.
  5. Positive Feedback: Highlight the positive aspects of the student’s work to encourage and motivate them.
  6. Corrective Feedback: Explicitly correct errors and explain language rules, ensuring the student understands the correct structure.
  7. Implicit Feedback: Use recasting as a quick way to provide corrective feedback implicitly, subtly correcting the error within a natural response.

Addressing syntax errors in bilingual education requires a balanced approach that includes immediate and specific feedback, attention to individual student needs, and a focus on positive reinforcement. By implementing these strategies, educators can help students navigate the complexities of syntax in both their L1 and L2, ultimately enhancing their language proficiency and academic success.

References:
  • Hamrick, P. (2014). A Role for Chunk Formation in Statistical Learning of Second Language Syntax. Language Learning, 64(2). https://doi.org/10.1111/lang.12049
  • Hartsuiker, R. J., & Bernolet, S. (2017). The development of shared syntax in second language learning. Bilingualism, 20(2). https://doi.org/10.1017/S1366728915000164

 

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More Posts

Teachers engaging in professional development for teaching emergent bilinguals using technology.

Professional Development on Teaching Emergent Bilinguals

I am convinced that professional development (PD) significantly influences the effectiveness of educators, which directly impacts language learners in our educational environments. Positive PD can transform teaching practices, leading to more engaging, inclusive, and effective instruction for language learners. Conversely, ineffective PD can result in stagnation, missed opportunities for growth, and, ultimately, suboptimal learning experiences for students. The Importance of PD for Emergent Bilinguals In my experience, when educators

Ugly Foods and Education

“Ugly Foods” and Education

As part of my work for different higher education institutions, I have been training future teachers and helping them in their certification processes as bilingual or English as second language teachers. Each semester, after making the required presentations and reviewing the expectations for the course, I always start every class by talking about the importance of two aspects that I

Finding Inspiration in Leonardo da Vinci’s Legacy

Science is defined as “the systematic study of the physical and natural world’s structure and behavior through observation and experimentation.” In Leonardo da Vinci’s work, we find the essence of that definition. For more than 40 years, Leonardo da Vinci gathered his observations and ideas in his now-famous Notebooks. In those notebooks, we can observe Leonardo’s systematic exploration of the

Our New Website - EnablingLearning.com

Our New Website

The year 2020 for us, as perhaps for many in the rest of the world, was a year full of uncertainties and challenges during which we have learned a lot both professionally and personally. Among the most fundamental things we have learned has been knowing how to appreciate every detail of our everyday life and not taking anything for granted

©​ Enabling Learning Blog 2024
EnablingLearning.com​
About Us

Scroll to Top
El acento escrito

¿Cómo colocarlo?

Si no sabes cómo colocar el acento escrito, te compartimos varios enlaces que te  pueden ayudar según sea el caso de tu dispositivo.

WindowsKeyboard shortcuts for international characters

WindowsHow to Type Characters with Accents on Windows

Mac OS and iOSEnter characters with accent marks on Mac

AndroidType in a different language